Stepped wedge cluster randomized controlled trial designs. Study design, participants, randomisation and masking. Issues in presentation and reporting of the design will be visited. A steppedwedge trial swt is one such pragmatic design and is similar to a parallel randomized controlled trial rct. The stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trial is a relatively new study design that is increasing in popularity.
Data analysis to determine the overall effectiveness of the intervention subsequently involves comparison of the data points in the control section of the wedge with those in the intervention section. We aimed to determine if the availability of hiv selftesting hivst would increase the frequency of testing among men who have sex with men msm attending university in china. Stepped wedge only has higher power because more data than parallel hussey and hughes. Planning and analysis of trials using a stepped wedge.
Clinical epidemiology program, ottawa hospital research institute. Planning and analysis of trials using a stepped wedge design part 26 of a serieson evaluation of scientific. Based on a pointbypoint evaluation, it was analyzed how these advantages and disadvantages applied to the specific clinical trial ceawatch netherlands. While outcomes might be collected at the individual e. All clusters that start the intervention at a given time point are collectively referred to as a wave or sequence. Small sample correction for the variance of gee estimators. In particular, to assess the intervention effect, we will use a poisson model with random site and provider within site effects. An important choice in the stepped wedge design is the number of clusters randomized at each time step. Data analysis to determine the overall effectiveness of the intervention subsequently involves comparison of the data points in the control section of. An example of the logistics of a stepped wedge trial design is shown in figure 1, which shows a stepped wedge design with five steps. For a standard steppedwedge design, the total sample size at each measurement time n tot, t i.
Generally, swts require smaller sample size to detect effects since they leverage both between and. Organisations are very large units of randomisation, but as. Analysing an open cohort steppedwedge clustered trial. Pdf stepped wedge randomised trial designs involve sequential rollout of an intervention to. Current issues in the design and analysis of stepped wedge trials.
A steppedwedge design is more efficient for the same number of units than a parallel group clusterrandomised trial when the intraclass correlation coefficient is relatively large and the cluster sizes are large, because each unit acts as its own control, reducing variability. Steppedwedge designs can be analyzed using a variety of techniques for longitudinal outcomes that allow for clustering and covariate effects. A pragmatic stepped wedge randomised cluster trial with repeated cross section design will be conducted. Background a stepped wedge cluster randomised trial swcrt is a. The stepped wedge cluster randomised trial is a novel research study design that is increasingly being used in the evaluation of service delivery type interventions. Stepped wedge designs incorporate data collection at each point where a new group step receives the intervention. I am looking for an advice on sample size and power calculation for an intervention study.
Spssx discussion mixed model for stepped wedge design. I am currently wrestling with how to analyze data from a steppedwedge designed cluster randomized trial. Hiv testing plays a central role in the combat against hiv. The unit of randomisation is the ward, with allocation by a random numbers table. The use of the steppedwedge cluster randomised trial swcrt is on the. The stepped wedge sw cluster randomized controlled trial crct design is being used with increasing frequency. The rhdsp rheumatic heart disease secondary prophylaxis trial was a stepped. Exploring the effect of implementation and context on a.
The analysis software will include methods to identify outlying data elements cluster, period, or cluster period with large influence on study results, to establish robustness as well as statistical options for finitesample bias corrections to account for the small numbers of clusters common to stepped wedge trials. The stepped wedge cluster randomised trial swcrt is increasingly being used to evaluate policy or service delivery interventions. Planning and analysis of trials using a stepped wedge design. Many studies which employ the stepped wedge design have few clusters but use methods of analysis which may require more clusters for unbiased and efficient intervention effect estimates. A few factors make this analysis particularly interesting.
Stepped wedge designs offer a number of opportunities for data analysis. Pdf using implementation facilitation to implement. Sample size calculations and analysis must make allowance for both the. Strengths and weaknesses of a stepped wedge cluster. Analysis of cluster randomised stepped wedge trials with repeated. In this study, the research team is developing and testing methods to improve the design and analysis of steppedwedge studies that enroll people in different ways, with different types of outcomes and missing data patterns. While the stepped wedge design offers a number of opportunities for use in future evaluations, a more consistent approach to reporting and data analysis is required. The prevention and reduction of weight loss in an acute. Analysis of cluster randomised stepped wedge trials with. Interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality are increasingly complex. At the level of individual programs and teams, staff members who are. The analysis of effect of pf on the abcs outcome measures in the context of a steppedwedge design will be based on a generalized linear mixed model glmm.
We undertook a randomised stepped wedge trial, a form of cluster randomised trial. A stepped wedge randomized controlled trial will be conducted in 4 provinces in china. Quasiexperimental designs in practicebased research. B virus hbv vaccination to a routine program of childhood vaccination in the gambia. The steppedwedge design involves the collection of observations during a baseline period in which no clusters are exposed to the intervention. Design and analysis of stepped wedge cluster randomized.
For a summary of the literature on the advantages and disadvantages of the stepped wedge design, see table 2, first column. A steppedwedge clusterrandomized design is similar to a cross over design in that each cluster receives both the treatment and control over time. Understanding how complex interventions are delivered, to whom, and how they work is key in ensuring their rapid scaleup. Introducing the new consort extension for steppedwedge cluster. Use it for all vertical and horizontal scenarios including pipe to pipe, pipe to fitting and fitting to fitting connections, in fact for every fitup imaginable. In a stepped wedge design more clusters are exposed to the intervention. Testing the use of practice facilitation in a cluster. Mixed effects approach to the analysis of the stepped wedge. Units act as their own control, so fewer units needed same as cross over design logistical or financial cannot introduce the intervention in all units at once evaluate the community effectiveness of an intervention previously shown to be efficacious in an individually. Moreover, the analysis of the stepped wedge design is more complex. In cluster randomized trials, the unit of randomization is the group rather than the individual.
First, we want to allow for the possibility that betweenperiod sitelevel correlation will decrease or decay over time. It can examine the clinical effectiveness of an intervention by using participants as the control group, address potential ethical issues, and extend time for trial implementation or. The stepped wedge cluster randomised trial swcrt is. Following this, at regular intervals, or steps, a cluster or group of clusters is randomized to receive the intervention and all participants are once again measured. In the steppedwedge design, all clusters in a trial will receive the intervention at some point, but the start of the intervention will be staggered. Improving delivery of secondary prophylaxis for rheumatic. Reporting quality of stepped wedge design randomized trials. The analysis software will include methods to identify outlying data elements cluster, period, or cluster period with large influence on study results, to establish robustness as well as statistical options for finitesample bias corrections to account for the small numbers of clusters common to steppedwedge trials. Approaches to the analysis of the design will also be covered focusing on the appropriate methods for the different outcomes. Stepped wedge design time in not balanced between intervention and control periods need to be able to measure outcome on each cluster, at each time step to control for time trends crosssectional or cohort sampling possible repeated measurements on members of a cohort may result in significant participant burden. If the correlation between baseline and followup is software for windows, developed by hemming and girling. However, there is a dearth of trials literature addressing analytical approaches to the swcrt. The optimal design of stepped wedge trials with equal allocation to sequences and a comparison to other trial designs show all authors. Examples of challenges in using the design will be explored.
University of birmingham the stepped wedge trial design. R statistical software was used to fit the linear mixed effects models and. There many be a variable number of clusters in each wave. Steppedwedge design in the steppedwedge design, all clusters in a trial will receive the intervention at some point, but the start of the intervention will be staggered. Best gap wedge for pipe fitters best gapping tool for pipe. An example of the logistics of a stepped wedge trial design is shown in figure figure1, 1, which shows a stepped wedge design with five steps. Sample size and power calculation stepped wedged design. Analysis compared tuberculosis episode rate before and.
However, there is limited published research on the quality of reporting of swcrcts. In addition, the clusters cross over in one direction onlytypically, from control to intervention. Perhaps as a result, a significant number of published trials have major methodological shortcomings, including failure to adjust for secular trends at the analysis stage. We delivered a vital signs triage intervention into routine maternity care in eight low and middleincome countries with the aim of reducing a composite outcome of morbidity and mortality. Second, there is possibly additional clustering at the patient level since individual outcomes will be. Developing new methods to conduct steppedwedge studies. In a steppedwedge design, however, the clusters switch or cross over in one direction only usually from the control group to the treatment group. Medline, ovid, web of knowledge, the cochrane library, psycinfo, the isrctn registry, and clinicaltrials. Effect of availability of hiv selftesting on hiv testing. Tests for two proportions in a steppedwedge cluster. A stepped wedge design is a type of crossover design in which different clusters cross over switch treatments at different time points.
After that, we multiply this total sample size by the variance inflation factors to account for the multilevel steppedwedge design. The study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of case managers intervention in improving linkage and retention rates to hiv care among newly diagnosed hivinfected persons. There is the need for research on the minimum number of. It is an alternative to parallel cluster trial designs, which are commonly used for the evaluation of service delivery or policy interventions delivered at the level of the cluster. Four groups of wards n 6 for three groups, n 7 for one group will be randomly allocated to each intervention time point over the trial.
The amount of time in each state control or intervention will differ for each site or group of sites if there are waves of more than one site starting up at the same time. The dogleg design is reminiscent of a stepped wedge design, but with a reduced schedule of assessments and with the notable difference that not all groups receive the intervention. Randomization and intervention initiation at the beginning of the trial, all clusters are randomized to an order, and assigned to a step based on that order random number generator can be used to assign order. The steppedwedge design swd of clinical trials has. Power analysis and sample size calculation are available. Stepped wedge trials with continuous recruitment require new ways. The optimal design of stepped wedge trials with equal. Reporting quality of stepped wedge design randomized. There is substantial variation in the design of stepped wedge trials. Results may help researchers conduct more rigorous studies using the steppedwedge design. Analysis of cluster randomised stepped wedge trials with repeated crosssectional samples.
Design and analysis of stepped wedge cluster randomized trials michael a. Mixed model for stepped wedge design administrator i think one reason there is so much confusion over analysis of crossover designs is that there are at least two ways to conceive of the design. The design involves random and sequential crossover of clusters from control to intervention until all clusters are exposed. Mixed effects approach to the analysis of the stepped. Stepped wedge designs are useful for phase iv trials, to evaluate the effect of time on the intervention, and as a way of dealing with logistic difficulties of implementing the intervention everywhere at once power is relatively insensitive to cv maximize the number of steps.
1220 1297 1060 1212 315 1187 1033 1428 424 45 1534 538 760 815 1276 1181 1170 412 853 1613 1390 272 71 440 1 114 399